Question 120
A solutions architect is reviewing this production AWS requirement: An application rotates an encryption key annually but needs to read S3 objects created under older encrypted data keys. Which design best fulfills the requirement?
Explanation
Correct Answer
AWS KMS automatic/on-demand rotation changes key material, not the logical key ID, and retains previous material for decrypt; it does not retroactively re-encrypt S3 data or make deletion of the KMS key safe. This design addresses the specific constraint: An application rotates an encryption key annually but needs to read S3 objects created under older encrypted data keys. A meaningful acceptance check is: An original S3 ciphertext decrypts through the same enabled key after rotation while new encryption uses the current key material; separately keyed older objects remain decryptable by their original keys.
Incorrect Answers
S3 Object Lock compliance mode prevents permanent deletion of a protected version even by account root; an ordinary versionless DeleteObject can still add a delete marker without deleting that retained version.
KMS key authorization is evaluated separately from the S3 bucket policy and supports controlled key administration.
S3 asynchronous CRR of SSE-KMS objects requires suitable replication role grants and KMS decrypt/encrypt permissions in each Region; a bucket replication rule alone is insufficient.