Question 110
At fictional Maple Telecom, the network architecture group is preparing a proposal for telecom operations offices during the business change review (case HPE7A11-1.3-043). The review identified this issue: a school district needs stronger identity-based segmentation but uses static VLAN requests as its only requirement. Which underlying campus architecture principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This principle is decisive because technical implementation proposals are not substitutes for business outcomes. The practical architecture response is to translate the business policy into user and device roles and allowed flows; the corresponding acceptance evidence is that the matrix tests permitted and denied access by identity and role.
Incorrect Answers
“Engineering requirements must account for operational feasibility” evaluates interpret technical requirements. The reported design gap is this: a school district needs stronger identity-based segmentation but uses static VLAN requests as its only requirement. The required response is “Technical implementation proposals are not substitutes for business outcomes.”.
This option — “Compatibility requirements must be reconciled with the security threat model” — checks interpret technical requirements, not whether the design resolves the stated fault: a school district needs stronger identity-based segmentation but uses static VLAN requests as its only requirement. The selected direct criterion is “Technical implementation proposals are not substitutes for business outcomes.”.
“Capacity requirements must use maximum credible demand” is a test of interpret technical requirements. That does not establish “Technical implementation proposals are not substitutes for business outcomes.” for the reported issue (a school district needs stronger identity-based segmentation but uses static VLAN requests as its only requirement).