Question 80
A clinical decision aid permits automatic override of expert judgments with no escalation path. The operations lead wants clear, testable remediation. What would be the strongest result to verify before closing the finding?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The key evidence is the observed result: usability tests show reviewers can reject and escalate unsafe suggestions. It is relevant because consequence-bearing decisions lack effective human oversight by design.
Incorrect Answers
This checks a different technical dependency: A single performance metric cannot establish fitness for the intended use. The case requires proof of “Usability tests show reviewers can reject and escalate unsafe suggestions”, which establishes the relevant condition: Consequence-bearing decisions lack effective human oversight by design.
That observation would verify a control associated with: Technical performance alone does not reveal consequences for vulnerable students. It does not establish the needed acceptance outcome. The direct evidence is “Usability tests show reviewers can reject and escalate unsafe suggestions”, testing: Consequence-bearing decisions lack effective human oversight by design.
“Pilot evidence documents performance, staff feedback and safe escalations” could occur while the stated failure remains unresolved. It tests: Pilot evidence documents performance, staff feedback and safe escalations. The required validation instead is “Usability tests show reviewers can reject and escalate unsafe suggestions”, because consequence-bearing decisions lack effective human oversight by design.