Question 90
At fictional Cedar Retail, a European privacy professional responsible for customer relationship platforms is reviewing lawful processing, transparency and international transfers during a data-subject rights exercise (CIPPE-III.B-023). The reported privacy issue is: A fitness app processes biometric measurements for health inference and considers ordinary consent wording sufficient for all Article 9 issues. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Special-category processing generally needs an additional Article 9 exception. The relevant response is to identify a qualifying Article 9 condition in addition to an appropriate Article 6 basis. The corresponding observation is that the legal register specifies both the lawful basis and special-category exception. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
“Vital interests may justify necessary processing in genuine life-critical circumstances.” concerns another compliance assessment: assess a relevant vital-interests basis and any applicable special-category condition. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: a fitness app processes biometric measurements for health inference and considers ordinary consent wording sufficient for all Article 9 issues. Special-category processing generally needs an additional Article 9 exception.
The compliance measure “GDPR recognizes specific health-care processing conditions subject to safeguards.” addresses assess relevant healthcare conditions and a lawful basis suited to clinical activity. The specific issue is that a fitness app processes biometric measurements for health inference and considers ordinary consent wording sufficient for all Article 9 issues; special-category processing generally needs an additional Article 9 exception.
“Article 6(1)(f) requires an interest, necessity and balancing assessment.” is relevant to document legitimate interest, necessity and a data-subject balancing assessment, but the question is about this situation: a fitness app processes biometric measurements for health inference and considers ordinary consent wording sufficient for all Article 9 issues. Special-category processing generally needs an additional Article 9 exception.