Question 470
At fictional Timberline Media, a European privacy professional responsible for digital audience analytics is reviewing lawful processing, transparency and international transfers during an internal compliance inspection (CIPPE-III.D-118). The reported privacy issue is: A European exporter signs SCCs and assumes contractual text alone makes third-country government access irrelevant. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Schrems II requires practical attention to the protection available in the destination. The relevant response is to evaluate third-country law and practices and necessary supplemental measures for the transfer. The corresponding observation is that the transfer assessment records residual access risks and adequate protections or stops transfer. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
“A data-residency promise alone does not establish complete Chapter V compliance.” concerns another compliance assessment: examine actual hosting, support access, onward recipients and relevant safeguards. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: a European exporter signs SCCs and assumes contractual text alone makes third-country government access irrelevant. Schrems II requires practical attention to the protection available in the destination.
The compliance measure “Effective transfer governance requires precise mapping of the processing arrangement.” addresses record the participating parties, purposes, categories and intended third-country disclosures. The specific issue is that a European exporter signs SCCs and assumes contractual text alone makes third-country government access irrelevant; schrems II requires practical attention to the protection available in the destination.
“Framework eligibility is recipient- and scope-dependent, not automatic for every US firm.” is relevant to confirm that the particular importer has relevant valid participation and that the transfer is covered, but the question is about this situation: a European exporter signs SCCs and assumes contractual text alone makes third-country government access irrelevant. Schrems II requires practical attention to the protection available in the destination.