Question 670
At fictional Westhaven Energy, a European privacy professional responsible for employee fleet systems is reviewing GDPR individual protections, concepts and security duties during a controller-processor governance workshop (CIPPE-II.C-168). The reported privacy issue is: A company refuses to search archived records for an access request without examining whether the records are retrievable. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Archived personal data can remain within an access request's scope. The relevant response is to assess the personal data held across systems and applicable access obligations and limits. The corresponding observation is that the search scope and any lawful exclusions are documented in the completed response. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
The compliance measure “Access and portability rights have different scopes and conditions.” addresses assess Article 15 access coverage without confusing it with the narrower portability scope. The specific issue is that a company refuses to search archived records for an access request without examining whether the records are retrievable; archived personal data can remain within an access request's scope.
“The Article 17 erasure right can arise when data are no longer necessary.” is relevant to assess erasure where the data are no longer necessary and no exception applies, but the question is about this situation: a company refuses to search archived records for an access request without examining whether the records are retrievable. Archived personal data can remain within an access request's scope.
This option focuses on evaluate Article 17 exceptions and preserve only data required by applicable law rather than the precise legal problem: a company refuses to search archived records for an access request without examining whether the records are retrievable. Archived personal data can remain within an access request's scope.