Question 60
At fictional Harbor Libraries, a European privacy professional responsible for public lending accounts is reviewing GDPR individual protections, concepts and security duties during a data inventory refresh (CIPPE-II.A-015). The reported privacy issue is: An online marketplace signs a processor contract while independently deciding new advertising purposes for the same transaction data. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Controller and processor status follows actual decisions and activities, not contract labels alone. The relevant response is to examine who actually determines purposes and essential means for each activity. The corresponding observation is that the role map differentiates service processing from the marketplace's own advertising decisions. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
“Biometric data processed to uniquely identify a person can trigger special-category rules.” is relevant to evaluate biometric processing for unique identification and the Article 9 restrictions, but the question is about this situation: an online marketplace signs a processor contract while independently deciding new advertising purposes for the same transaction data. Controller and processor status follows actual decisions and activities, not contract labels alone.
“The GDPR definition of data subject concerns an identified or identifiable living natural person.” concerns another compliance assessment: determine whether the GDPR protects living natural persons while checking relevant national rules separately. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: an online marketplace signs a processor contract while independently deciding new advertising purposes for the same transaction data. Controller and processor status follows actual decisions and activities, not contract labels alone.
The compliance measure “Article 9 addresses special categories separately from ordinary personal data.” addresses determine whether genetic information belongs to a GDPR special category for the identified person. The specific issue is that an online marketplace signs a processor contract while independently deciding new advertising purposes for the same transaction data; controller and processor status follows actual decisions and activities, not contract labels alone.