Question 230
At fictional Harbor Libraries, a European privacy professional responsible for public lending accounts is reviewing lawful processing, transparency and international transfers during an internal compliance inspection (CIPPE-III.B-058). The reported privacy issue is: A platform treats default silence on an optional data-sharing request as an affirmative GDPR consent. Which observation most directly verifies that the privacy correction is working?
Explanation
Correct Answer
The observation that best addresses the stated issue is: Audit records show a clear granular affirmative signal before optional sharing. It supports the decision to obtain an unambiguous affirmative choice meeting Article 4 and Article 7 requirements. The applicable principle is that valid consent generally cannot be inferred from silence or inactivity. The observation must be checked in the real processing context.
Incorrect Answers
“The delivery works without unrelated preference collection.” concerns another compliance assessment: limit contract-based processing to what is objectively necessary for the agreed service. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: a platform treats default silence on an optional data-sharing request as an affirmative GDPR consent. Valid consent generally cannot be inferred from silence or inactivity.
The compliance measure “The marketing activity stops when no defensible alternative basis exists.” addresses review lawful-basis choice honestly and assess whether another basis was validly available before processing. The specific issue is that a platform treats default silence on an optional data-sharing request as an affirmative GDPR consent; valid consent generally cannot be inferred from silence or inactivity.
This option focuses on assess public-task or official-authority grounds established by applicable law rather than the precise legal problem: a platform treats default silence on an optional data-sharing request as an affirmative GDPR consent. Valid consent generally cannot be inferred from silence or inactivity.