Question 250
At fictional Summit Agriculture, a European privacy professional responsible for worker scheduling is reviewing lawful processing, transparency and international transfers during a scheduled privacy design review (CIPPE-III.B-063). The reported privacy issue is: A controller switches from consent to legitimate interest after a person withdraws solely to continue the identical optional campaign. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Lawful-basis selection should not be manipulated to defeat withdrawal rights. The relevant response is to review lawful-basis choice honestly and assess whether another basis was validly available before processing. The corresponding observation is that the marketing activity stops when no defensible alternative basis exists. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
“Contractual necessity is narrower than processing merely mentioned in standard terms.” concerns another compliance assessment: limit contract-based processing to what is objectively necessary for the agreed service. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: a controller switches from consent to legitimate interest after a person withdraws solely to continue the identical optional campaign. Lawful-basis selection should not be manipulated to defeat withdrawal rights.
The compliance measure “Research purposes receive tailored treatment but are not a blanket exemption.” addresses assess lawful basis, Article 9 conditions if relevant and Article 89 research safeguards. The specific issue is that a controller switches from consent to legitimate interest after a person withdraws solely to continue the identical optional campaign; lawful-basis selection should not be manipulated to defeat withdrawal rights.
This option focuses on examine necessity, competing individual rights and context before relying on Article 6(1)(f) rather than the precise legal problem: a controller switches from consent to legitimate interest after a person withdraws solely to continue the identical optional campaign. Lawful-basis selection should not be manipulated to defeat withdrawal rights.