Question 260
At fictional Vista Museums, a European privacy professional responsible for heritage archive requests is reviewing GDPR individual protections, concepts and security duties during a compliance launch checkpoint (CIPPE-II.C-065). The reported privacy issue is: An automated loan decision has a similarly significant effect but a bank claims Article 22 never applies to finance algorithms. Which European data-protection principle best explains the appropriate response?
Explanation
Correct Answer
This is the governing legal or privacy principle for the case: Article 22 protection depends on the decision's effect and degree of automation. The relevant response is to assess whether the decision is solely automated and legally or similarly significantly affects the individual. The corresponding observation is that the record identifies Article 22 applicability and any permitted exception and safeguard. The actual law and jurisdiction remain determinative.
Incorrect Answers
“GDPR rights restrictions require a proper legislative basis and safeguards.” is relevant to evaluate whether a valid Union or Member State legislative restriction meets Article 23 conditions, but the question is about this situation: an automated loan decision has a similarly significant effect but a bank claims Article 22 never applies to finance algorithms. Article 22 protection depends on the decision's effect and degree of automation.
“Rights requests are ordinarily free of charge under Article 12.” concerns another compliance assessment: provide an ordinarily free response, considering lawful exceptional fee grounds only where justified. It would not by itself resolve the described concern: an automated loan decision has a similarly significant effect but a bank claims Article 22 never applies to finance algorithms. Article 22 protection depends on the decision's effect and degree of automation.
The compliance measure “Not every profiling activity triggers the Article 22 decision prohibition.” addresses distinguish ordinary profiling from solely automated decisions with legal or similarly significant effects. The specific issue is that an automated loan decision has a similarly significant effect but a bank claims Article 22 never applies to finance algorithms; article 22 protection depends on the decision's effect and degree of automation.